kilativ (kilativ) wrote,
kilativ
kilativ

Про ленд-лиз

Из англоязычного источника:
Another myth has it that the Soviets could not have survived or won WWII without massive American Lend-Lease. Lend-Lease clearly helped, and Soviet successes in the second half of the war would not have been as dramatic without the hundreds of thousands of American jeeps and trucks that improved logistics and allowed for deep advances. And American airplanes were greatly appreciated – the Soviets’ second highest scoring fighter ace of the war downed most of his kills while flying an American P-39 Airacobra.
However, the bulk of Lend-Lease did not arrive until 1944-1945, by which point the Soviets were already nearing victory. Indeed, meaningful amounts of Lend-Lease did not begin arriving until late 1943, by which point the Soviets had already halted the German advance and gone on the counteroffensive, rolling back German gains and beginning the relentless march westward that ended in Berlin and Central Europe.
By the time the bulk of Lend-Lease arrived, the Soviets already had significant accomplishments under their belts and were well on the way to winning the war, including halting the Germans at the Battle of Moscow in 1941; major victories at Stalingrad and Kursk in 1943; liberating the Ukraine and reaching Poland in the winter of 1943-1944; and shattering Army Group Center in Operation Bagration in 1944.
It all comes down to when the Lend-Lease equipment was delivered. US commitments and promises of Lend-Lease were made early, beginning in 1941. But a variety of factors caused significant time to elapse before the US could make good on those commitments, starting with the time needed for American factories to transition from peacetime production of civilian goods to a war footing. Moreover, America had her own rapidly expanding military – 16 million men were put in uniform during the war – to arm and equip, which was often a higher priority than Lend-Lease.
Additionally, deliveries, especially during the war’s first year, were further delayed by a perception that the USSR might collapse at any moment, so Lend-Lease equipment could simply end up as German war booty. Because of such fears, on more than one occasion during the Soviets’ darkest hours in 1941-1942, ships loaded with Lend-Lease destined for the USSR were either offloaded and the equipment redistributed to the US military, or the ships were diverted to Britain and the equipment given to the British instead.
Even when the goods were ready and fears of Soviet collapse had receded, it took years to establish reliable routes. Deliveries were initially routed across the Arctic Ocean to Murmansk, but it was a hazardous passage in which many convoys were decimated by German planes and submarines operating from Norway. The quantities delivered were more symbolic than meaningful, and were of use only in the peripheral Arctic fronts facing Finland.
Another more meaningful was through Iran, which the Allies occupied precisely for that purpose, but the road and rail infrastructure necessary for the delivery of significant aid was not completed until the second half of 1943. Aid through this route went mainly to the Soviets’ southern fronts, which were more important than the northern ones supplied through Murmansk, but were not the main front.
The main supply route, through which Lend-Lease finally gushed like a torrent, was through Vladivostok and thence across the Trans-Siberian railway to the central fronts and the Soviets’ main war effort. However, that was the most difficult route that took the longest time to establish, requiring not only significant work on the Soviet end, but the creation of an entire road and rail network from scratch, across Alaska and Western Canada, to handle the massive mountains of aid.

Собственно говоря, советские историки были правы: ленд-лиз не сыграл значительной роли в победе. Грубо говоря, до 1942 года он был объявлен, но его по сути не было, поскольку союзники ожидали уничтожения СССР и не хотели тратить ресурсы, которых у самих было не очень много, а основная часть грузов пошла вообще ближе к 1944, после открытия Иранского пути и наконец-то заработавших поставок через Владивосток/Транссиб. Если русские смогли сломать хребет Гитлеру к 1943, разгромив его армии под Сталинградом и на Курской дуге, то о какой РЕШАЮЩЕЙ роли ленд-лиза можно говорить? Помощь была, никто не отрицает, ноостальное - домыслы.
Кстати, почитайте всю статью, где опровергаются мифы о второй мировой. Там практически один в один говорится то, о чем давно говорили советы и опровергается ложь постперестроечных борцунов с красными
Tags: ВОВ, история
Subscribe

Recent Posts from This Journal

  • Для коллег

    Порядок в статье первых трех авторов с равным вкладом определялся по игре супермарио. О как!

  • Случай на улице

    Иду вчера домой и на пересечении второй авеню и 15 улицы, около украинской униатской церкви - картина маслом. Гигантский автобус, поворачивая на 15…

  • Дорожное

    У нас в городе есть такая шняга как выделенная для автобусов полоса. Иногда нужно с неё повернуть направо. Так вот, когда на неё можно заезжать для…

  • Post a new comment

    Error

    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

  • 58 comments

Recent Posts from This Journal

  • Для коллег

    Порядок в статье первых трех авторов с равным вкладом определялся по игре супермарио. О как!

  • Случай на улице

    Иду вчера домой и на пересечении второй авеню и 15 улицы, около украинской униатской церкви - картина маслом. Гигантский автобус, поворачивая на 15…

  • Дорожное

    У нас в городе есть такая шняга как выделенная для автобусов полоса. Иногда нужно с неё повернуть направо. Так вот, когда на неё можно заезжать для…